In today’s real estate industry, being average is becoming increasingly dangerous.
Nick Schlekeway, founder and CEO of Amherst Madison and author of The Essential Agent, has spent more than a decade studying what happens to agents who fail to differentiate themselves. His conclusion is simple: average is invisible.
Nick joins James Dwiggins and Keith Robinson to explain why the middle of the real estate industry is disappearing and why a smaller group of highly differentiated professionals is capturing more of the business. For agents, becoming essential means developing expertise, communicating a clear value proposition, and giving consumers a reason to specifically choose you.
They discuss:
- Why “average is invisible” in today’s real estate industry
- The “rookie mentality” that keeps successful people learning and growing
- Why great leadership requires leading by example
- How agents can become essential instead of disposable
- Why agents should “say old things to new people”
Nick also shares the turning point from his own early career. After writing more than 30 contracts in six months without getting one accepted, he decided he would either become a true professional with a defined process or leave the real estate industry altogether. That decision changed the trajectory of his career and eventually helped shape the brokerage he built.
The lesson for anyone competing in the real estate industry is clear: expertise matters, differentiation matters, and average is increasingly easy for consumers to ignore.
If you want to build a business that lasts, stop trying to appeal to everyone. Figure out what makes you essential, become exceptional at it, and make sure the market knows exactly why you’re different.
Links mentioned in the episode:
Connect with our guest, Nick Schlekeway:
Learn more about Amherst Madison:
Unlock Conference by Zillow
The industry is evolving. The question is: will your business evolve with it? Join us at Zillow Unlock 2026 and be part of the conversation shaping what comes next.
Secure your ticket at www.unlockconference.com and use discount code REIU20 for 20% off your ticket.
Code can be used on all full priced passes leading up to the event and cannot be combined with any other discounts.
Lock in your spot now before the price goes up.
Subscribe on YouTube
Subscribe to Real Estate Insiders Unfiltered on YouTube!
Become a Sponsor
To learn more about becoming a sponsor of the show send us an email: jessica@inman.com
Our Merch
You asked for it. We delivered. Check out our new merch!
Connect With Us
Follow Real Estate Insiders Unfiltered Podcast on Instagram – YouTube – Facebook – TikTok.
This podcast is produced by Two Brothers Creative.
