Phillip Cantrell, a 43-year veteran who founded Benchmark Realty in 2006, provides an elegant and systems-focused perspective on entrepreneurial growth and residential real estate leadership. His company has grown from one desk in his living room to nearly 2,000 agents across multiple states, closing approximately $5 billion in annual sales in a fee-based model.
Phillip recounts the critical turning point in 2008 when the mortgage crisis hit and his largest builder client poached seven of his 13 agents, leaving him “staring at the abyss”. This failure forced a radical pivot from a traditional 80/20 split to a fee-based model, which allowed for extreme profitability through scale. He focused on attracting experienced, high-producing agents (“didn’t hire newbies”) and prioritizing excellence and training over technology.
His key to overcoming adversity is the philosophical concept of “the power in the pause”. He explains that between stimulus and response, there is a space where leaders choose their reaction. The difficulty is that humans are “lazy” and automatically respond without thinking. As a self-professed 98% left brain thinker, Phillip systematized every aspect of the business, viewing documentation (compliance, onboarding, etc.) as crucial to the brand’s culture and scalability.
Phillip sold Benchmark to United Real Estate Group in 2020. He advises that anyone considering selling must be prepared for rigorous due diligence (“stripped down naked”) and must ensure their systems and financials are clean. He maintains his consulting role with United (EVP of Strategy) to keep CEO Dan Duffy “grounded”, underscoring the importance of finding partners whose strengths plug your weaknesses. His leadership philosophy is based on the speed of the leader and maintaining an internal code of ethics: “You muck up, you’re out of here, son”.
His book, Failing My Way to Success, details his business history (four wins, six losses) and teaches his core principle, inspired by Earl Nightingale: money is the scoreboard of your service to others. By focusing on service and meeting needs (“help enough people get what they want”), financial success follows naturally.
Links mentioned in the show:
Episode with Dan Duffy: Making Mergers & Acquisitions Work in the Long
For Phillip’s book check out: https://www.phillipcantrell.com/
Connect with Phillip on Instagram – Facebook – LinkedIn.
Subscribe to Real Estate Insiders Unfiltered on YouTube!
To learn more about becoming a sponsor of the show send us an email: jessica@inman.com
You asked for it. We delivered. Check out our new merch!
Follow Real Estate Insiders Unfiltered Podcast on Instagram – YouTube – Facebook – TikTok.
This podcast is produced by Two Brothers Creative.
